SHARE Share Button Share Button SHARE

Straits tunnel is a brilliant scam

BY BARBARA STAMIRIS

The Enbridge Great Lakes tunnel is a brilliant scam. Just proposing a tunnel has kept Line 5 oil and profit flowing. No need to actually build it.

When it reaches Wisconsin, the Alberta pipeline branches into Great Lakes Line 5 and Line 78 around the lakes. Both lines go to Sarnia. Enbridge chooses the Great Lakes route purely for profit.

When Line 5 shut down for 20 days, following the Aug. 25 spill of natural gas liquids in Wisconsin, much of the Line 5 oil was rerouted to Line 78 around Chicago. Unlike Enbridge doomsday predictions, gas prices and propane supply were unaffected. The loss of Line 5 went unnoticed.

Risking Earth’s largest freshwater system with a damaged 73-year-old pipeline is a needless risk when the land route is newer, safer and can carry most of Line 5’s oil today. But Line 5 earns $6 billion a decade, so Enbridge proposed a tunnel to keep all 645 miles of Line 5 operating indefinitely. The Coast Guard considers the stretch of Line 5 along US2 at the base of the Upper Peninsula to be at highest risk of rupture and spill into Lake Michigan. The real purpose of the tunnel plan is to keep old Line 5 operating.

And Enbridge only needs to promise the tunnel, not build it. That’s because, in 2018, Michigan’s then-Gov. Rick Snyder said Line 5 could operate until its tunnel was completed. So if a tunnel is never completed, Line 5 just keeps going.

By engaging regulatory agencies and the public with its tunnel pretense, Enbridge has extended Line 5 operation for almost a decade already. Enbridge’s claim that the tunnel will protect the Great Lakes convinced many, but boring a tunnel for 6 years directly below still-operating Line 5, increases Great Lakes danger.

The Enbridge Board of Directors has not approved the tunnel project. It’s a phantom tunnel, yet it keeps Line 5 operating.

In July, the Michigan Supreme Court ruled that tunnel permits had not considered the environmental impact of extending Line 5 operation or of feasible and prudent alternatives to it. In September, Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer told Enbridge that Line 5 had to go, not wait another decade for a tunnel. But as long as tunnel debate and litigation continues, so does Line 5 oil.

Until Line 5 is safely decommissioned, its danger grows. The Enbridge tunnel scam keeps Line 5 going 25 years beyond its design life, before a shovel ever hits the ground.

It is a brilliant scam and it almost worked, until the Michigan Supreme Court saw through it.

Gov. Whitmer and EGLE are now reviewing all tunnel permits in light of the court ruling. Call on them (517-335-7856) to deny November’s final tunnel permit.

If Line 5 is still operating when Gov. Jocelyn Benson takes office, she must decommission Line 5 to finish the job. (Decommissioning provides more Michigan jobs than building a tunnel.)

We need action, not words, to save the Great Lakes.

About the author: Barbara Stamiris of Traverse City is a longtime environmental activist.

Stamiris

SHARE Share Button Share Button SHARE